Dan's Wild Wild Science Journal
Welcome at » Science

Note: You are on the old site of the Wild Weather Journal- Go HERE to read this post on the AGU Blogosphere!

You have likely heard about the Large Hadron Collider. You probably even now they are searching for an elusive atomic particle called the Higgs Bosun.

Want to know why it’s so important and just how incredible the LHC machine is?

Watch this video and then watch an explanation by Brian Cox that I posted last week.

Thanks for letting me know. I'll shop somewhere that isn't trying to scam me.

You are on the OLD home of the Wild Wild Science Journal. Click the image to go to the new one on the AGU Blogosphere!

No blog post I’ve ever written has had more comment than the one about these so called “magic power bracelets” being sold on cable TV.

You know the ads- They promise this little bracelet will harness your bodies natural energy field and correct all kinds of problems. Issues like balance and the sudden urge to eat dog food among others. They don’t, however, seem to correct the urge to throw money away.

While skimming the blogosphere tonight, I see Phil Plait on Bad Astronomy has a post up about the University of Colorado Athletic Department. They are licensing their logo to be sold on these bracelets. That left me utterly dumbfounded.

Then I find this. It’s on a well known news site. These people are in college! You know, that place where you are supposed to pick up some knowledge!

I’ve no idea who Vincent Velasquez is, but I think he missed a great opportunity to pass on some good information to his readers. Instead, he likely inspired a lot of people to throw their money away.
Several MD’s have emailed me to say thank you for telling people about these hoax bracelets. Here is a link to a medical opinion about them.

Just to be clear, one more time.

This is  QUACKERY.

iPower, iRenew, Power Balance they are all the same.

They are lying to you. There is no such thing as an energy field around your body. If there was, this little piece of plastic wouldn’t control it.

My favourite quote is by Physicist Neil deGrasse Tyson. It’s very apropos here: “The laws of physics are real, everything else is just politics.”

A note to my alma-mater, The University of Oklahoma: If you start licensing this kind of quackery, you can save the stamp on that letter you send me each year asking for money.

For those of you about to write me and tell me that you bought one, and that it has actually curbed you urge to eat dog food, etc. Let me ask you to read this first.

Most people in science see this kind of thing and just shake their heads. We live in an age where science needs to stand up and not be afraid to call something like this out. With America 21st in the world in maths and 25th in science, it’s even more imperative.

Note this blog is now part of the AGU Blogs- Go here! I will double post for awhile but please bookmark the new site. There are other great Earth science blogs at AGU as well.

Image from National Climate Data Center/NOAA

The incredible warmth globally this year has continued into October across America. Almost the entire 48 states were above normal in October. The Mountain West and the North were the warmest.

From Gerald Meehl Nat. Centers For Atmospheric Research

This warmth also shows up in the temperature extremes. Nationwide, there were 1544 new record highs in October. Only 321 record lows were set.

This trend has actually been increasing for decades now.  Is it another sign of our warming global climate? I wrote a post on this awhile back.

It now seems that 2010 will be no different. The trend continues. Over 2 record highs for every record low.

What makes this even more incredible is that we have a strong La Nina in the Pacific right now. La Nina’s are (in many, but not all) ways the opposite of El Nino. Look at the ocean temperatures on the image to the right. A large area of colder than normal water is cooling the air over the Pacific Ocean. This actually cools the planet down some (about 0.1° C). El Nino’s warm us up about the same amount.

From NOAA-ESRL- Blue is below normal water temperature. The La Nina in the Equatorial Pacific shows up clearly. It's been developing since August. Click for a much larger image.

In spite of this, 2010 may end up being the warmest year globally on record. With the La Nina in full bore, we still set 8 record highs for every record low in October.

We are almost certainly witnessing something that has not been seen in thousands of years. A major shift in the planet’s climate.

While there are month to month and even decade to decade fluctuations in the global temperature, there is nothing left to explain the  long term rise. Everything except rising greenhouse gases have been ruled out…

NASA image

(Reminder that this blog is now part of the AGU Blogosphere at http://blogs.agu.org/wildwildscience/ Check them out!)

I’ve often wondered about something. Suppose a 1000 meter wide space rock  were to hit Nashville TN. Would I survive here in Huntsville in North Alabama?

It would depend on many factors of course. Nashville is about 165 km to my north. That’s a BIG factor.   The size of the asteroid, and the angle of impact, are others.

Let’s say that it hit at a 60 degree angle and was a rather dense mix of rock with some ice. The ground in Nashville is made up of sedimentary rock, so that will also be a factor.

What’s the answer?

Do I survive? Probably not.

The scenario I am about to give you is based on IMPACT EARTH. It’s a program put together by scientists at Purdue University and Imperial College in London. They have recently updated the physics and you can check it out yourself online here.

So what would I experience at a distance of 165 kilometers?

The rock would begin to break up at about 70 km above the surface. I assumed an initial speed of 25 km /second. It would be slowed only very slightly by our atmosphere and hit the surface traveling 24.7 km/ second. The fragments of the asteroid would hit the ground over a relatively small area. An ellipse of around 1000 meters to 1500 meters.

The crater formed would be 16 km wide! That is over 10 miles for metrically challenged Americans.

At the time of impact everything down to 4 km would be vaporized. The vaporized earth and buildings would fill the crater back in and it would only be around 700 meters deep at the end. Downtown Nashville would be gone before anyone there knew it. They might have a couple of seconds warning at most.

The blast in Nashville would produce the same energy as nearly 6,000 15 megaton hydrogen bombs detonated at once.

Let’s assume I’m outside walking the dog in Big Spring Park in the middle of  Huntsville. The flash in the sky as the rock hit the atmosphere would last only 2-4 seconds. It would be silent. No noise. The impact fireball would look 16 times larger than the sun.

If it’s sunny, walk outside and look up at the sun. Close your eyes and feel the warmth. The heat from the blast 165 km away would feel 27 times hotter than that. The heat would be instantaneous.

The Tunguska event in Siberia was from a much smaller space rock than we are talking about here. It leveled the forest for 200 miles around the impact.

I would suffer third degree burns and trees and grass around me will catch on fire. If I were inside when it hit, the burns would be less severe. Most of the city would still be alive.

It would still be quiet.

As I looked around in pain from the burns, I would see fires everywhere. People would be rushing outside to see what was happening.

33 seconds after the impact, Huntsville would feel an earthquake of magnitude 7.9.  Most well built buildings would not collapse but many people will be injured by falling objects. It would probably knock me off my feet in Big Spring Park.

The fireball in the northern sky would be huge but about 2 minutes later a black cloud would soon be visible. This black cloud would be made of gravel sized rocks and very fine dust. The ejecta cloud arrives in Huntsville 3 minutes after the impact. It’s now very dark with fires burning as the ground shakes.

Hell would rain down for 5 more minutes. It’s not over though.

What winds over 300 km/hr (200 mph) will do to a home. This image is from the aftermath of an EF3 tornado in Oklahoma. Courtesy NOAA/NWS

Eight minutes after the impact an explosion so loud it will cause excruciating ear pain will be heard. Almost immediately, a blast of wind will hit the city. Winds will increase briefly to over 90 meters per second. That’s over 200 mph.

Even strong buildings will likely collapse. Anyone outside will literally be blown away. Frame houses that were on fire seconds before will be blown away.

How about those who are further south? The winds in Birmingham would only reach hurricane force. The thermal blast would not cause burns. Heavy damage from the 7.9 magnitude quake would be likely.

Astronomers think that objects like I described hit Earth twice every million years. Objects big enough to destroy a large city hit Earth every 3 centuries on average. The Tunguska event in Siberia in 1908 was one of these.

The rock that wiped out the dinosaurs was 10 km wide. Those type events are thought to happen only once every 300 million years or so.

Just something to think about…

Dan

sources:

Impact Earth Calculator- http://www.purdue.edu/impactearth

http://impact.ese.ic.ac.uk/ImpactEffects/effects.pdf

http://www.gps.caltech.edu/~sue/TJA_LindhurstLabWebsite/ListPublications/Papers_pdf/Seismo_1747.pdf

Andrea Milani (20 June 2003)
Science 300 (5627), 1882. [DOI: 10.1126/science.1077708]

Note: Please bookmark the new site on AGU Blogs for the Wild Wild Science Journal- http://blogs.agu.org/wildwildscience/

I will continue to double post here and there for sometime..

People often ask if a flood, a snowstorm, or a hot summer was caused by climate change. The correct answer is to say that no one weather event can be blamed on climate change, but certain weather events become more likely to occur.

Here in the Southeast U.S. we had a very hot summer. Downright brutal actually. The hottest on record in many cities. Atlanta had one of it’s worst droughts ever recorded a couple of summers ago. There have also been some massive floods. Nashville was hit by what can only be described as a flood that might come once every 500 years.

Extreme weather events happen. You can count on it.  It makes my job forecasting the weather extremely fascinating.

The question a group of atmospheric scientists asked recently is this. “Are extreme summer weather events becoming more frequent in the Southeast.”

The answer was a definite yes. The question then becomes-

WHY?

This is where an incredibly useful data set comes in. It will take a second to explain but believe me it’s worth it.

Several times each day, high speed computers use weather balloon data and surface observations to build a 3 dimensional model of the atmosphere. Ship reports and data from weather satellites are also used.

This analysis is used to give numerical weather prediction models a starting point. You cannot predict weather in the future unless you know mathematically what the weather is doing now. If you want to forecast for the globe, you need to know a starting point for the entire planet!

A few years back scientists had an idea. Why not use modern methods of making a global analysis and go back in time. Ship reports and weather balloons have been around a lot longer than high speed computers. The very sophisticated methods of coming up with an analysis of the atmosphere could be used to build a data set of the atmosphere for the past 60+ years!

They did just that.

In Europe the European Center for Medium Range Forecasting did it as well. They use a slightly different way of making the first guess for the numerical weather models, so we have two close but not identical data sets.

A new paper being published in the Journal of Climate contends that the increasing extreme summer weather over the Southeast U.S. is due to semi permanent high pressure cell over the Atlantic. The official name of  this system is the NASH. That stands for North Atlantic Subtropical High. Most meteorologists call it the Bermuda High.

The Bermuda High pumps warm moist air into the Gulf Coast States all summer and brings plenty of rain to the region. Summer thunderstorms are a common occurrence. Tropical cyclones are also steered by the big high pressure system. Sometimes right into the Gulf of Mexico and sometimes around it and out to sea.

Every now and then, the high pressure center will move westward, closer to the mainland and drift north a bit. This brings very hot and dry weather to the region. When the high moves close and drops southward, it gets very wet and stormy.

Dr. Wenhong Li and colleagues found that the Bermuda High is behaving strangely now. It’s getting stronger and moving westward. It’s also drifting North and South more than in the past. They show in their paper that the drought and flood weather over the Southeast is directly related to this.

So, why is this happening?

It could be long term oscillations in the ocean/atmosphere system. These are well known. The Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO) could be involved. So could the Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO). The PDO and the AMO are long duration changes in ocean temperatures which affect weather patterns. These patterns have been occurring naturally for at least a millennium. Very likely for much, much longer.

It’s not the AMO or the PDO.

Li and his colleagues checked it out and the correlation between them and the Bermuda High movements is very poor. In other words, the behavior of the Bermuda High does not seem to be related to the AMO/PDO.

Could it be climate change?

They compared the behavior of the Bermuda High in the past using the reanalysis data sets and also looked at a series of climate models. They first used 23 models to look at how the NASH behaved when greenhouse gases were set to pre-industrial levels. They saw behavior consistent with the reanalysis prior to 1980.

They then looked at a set of climate models with more realistic modern day levels of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. They found increased correlation. In other words, the Bermuda High starts behaving more like what has been seen since 1980.

They then looked at a set of 23 different models with rising greenhouse gases until the CO2 levels double in the year 2100. It’s very likely this will happen if we continue as we are now.

They found even more correlation with the behavior of the Bermuda High seen in the last 30 years. The average of these future climate models show extreme droughts and rain events over the Southeast as the Bermuda High gets stronger and moves westward.

Here is a quote directly from the paper:

“Our attribution analysis suggests that global warming seems to be contributing to the changes of the NASH.

It will be interesting to see the reaction to this paper. I already know it will get plenty of press, but I’m interested in what other climate researchers think. Did they overlook anything, make a mistake in the statistical analysis, etc.

If not, then we can say with some confidence that the brutally hot summer of 2010 was indeed at least partially due to climate change.  So was that flood in Nashville. So was that drought that almost shut off Atlanta’s water supply in 2007.

The real science is a bit scarier than what you see on cable news isn’t it.

Sources:

NOAA http://www.aoml.noaa.gov/phod/amo_faq.php

Changes to the North Atlantic Subtropical High and Its Role in the Intensification of Summer Rainfall Variability in the Southeastern United States

Wenhong Li, Laifang Li, Rong Fu, Yi Deng and Hui Wang

doi: 10.1175/2010JCLI3829.1 (http://journals.ametsoc.org/doi/abs/10.1175/2010JCLI3829.1?journalCode=clim)

Current CO2 Level in the Atmosphere